The Home of Fantasy Sports Analysis

Starting Pitcher Barometer: Grab the Turnbull by the Horns

Guys and dolls, I knew starting pitching was rough coming into the season. The fact that seemingly half of our “aces” have been imploding early on hasn’t helped things. There’s some chatter of the balls being “juiced” again, which not only makes me want to squeeze some kiwis but also makes me fret about my starting pitchers.

The rankings have felt surprisingly malleable outside of the top 30 already. There was also a cluster of starters I expected a bit more from who have been so bad I dropped them from the list. Speaking of which, by request, I have added another feature to this weekly Barometer: those who dropped off the list. That will appear at the bottom of this piece. We’re almost a month into the season and we’re getting a better sense of the pitching landscape. Let’s begin with a special look at what on earth is happening in Atlanta.

Starting Pitcher Barometer

The Atlanta Rotation

This past week the Braves have been making some necessary moves. Kyle Wright clearly wasn’t ready for the limelight just yet and will head back to Triple-A to work on his control. More surprisingly, Sean Newcomb will meet Wright there to do the same. Newcomb allowed more runs (8) and walks (6) than he had strikeouts (5) over his first three starts with a startling 6.86 SIERA. Newcomb has never had good command nor a plus breaking pitch and could should wind up being a bullpen piece.

They brought up Touki Toussaint, who will join the rotation (at least temporarily). He’s an electric pitcher to watch but has always struggled to stay consistent with his mechanics, leading to high walk rates. He’s worth a look if you have a spot to play with, but I’m keeping my expectations in check until I see improved control. Also new to the list is Max Fried, who I had actually expected to get bounced from the rotation before Wright and Bryse Wilson. Fried has allowed just two earned runs over his 19.2 IP though (despite his minuscule 5.49 K/9) and will stick around for at least a little while longer.

I’ll briefly mention Kevin Gausman, who, to this point, has yet to totally tick us off. He’s been downright impressive, even! He’s finally throwing the crap out of his splitter at 34%, which is fueling his 14.9% swinging strike rate. Why it took him seven years and two organizations to finally learn to throw his best pitch more is beyond me. Finally, that brings us to Mike Soroka. He’s fresh off the IL and looked good in his first 2019 MLB start. I’m throwing him right into mixed league ownership territory at SP49. Just be wary of his shoulder issues.

The Risers

  • Joe Musgrove, PIT (+35) – I had done Musgrove dirty with my prior ranking. Upon further inspection in my Fire & Ice this week, I love what he’s doing. He deserved a huge bump. Check the link for more deets.
  • Sonny Gray, CIN (+26) – I unceremoniously lambasted ol’ Sonny Boy (who has a ceremony for a lambasting, anyway?) following his first brutal start. He gave up three runs over 2.2 innings with four walks and zero strikeouts, giving PTSD to all who rode the Sonnycoaster in 2018. Since then, however, he’s made three starts totaling 16.2 IP with a 2.16 ERA / 0.54 WHIP and a 22:2 K:BB ratio. It could have been even nicer, but a comebacker shortened his Miami start thanks to some calf soreness. He didn’t use his slider and rarely went to the sinker in his first start, which was so abbreviated it could just be noise. Since then, however, he’s been using the sinker and slider more with much less four-seam usage. His lack of whiffs and chases out of the zone is concerning, but he looks like he belongs on the list at the very least.

The Fallers

  • Miles Mikolas, STL (-29) – The shiny, sparkly luster Mikolas had in 2018 is quickly fading into rusty pewter. We knew his game wasn’t centered around strikeouts, but dang Mikolas, a 6.2% SwStr% and 4.71 K/9? Woof. While the 19.2% HR/FB has been inflated, you’re just asking for trouble when you’re pitching to an extreme amount of contact. Even with his 6.00 ERA, he has had a “fortunate” BABIP at .275. You’ve gotta bench him until you see some improvement.
  • Rick Porcello, BOS (-33) – Speaking of pitchers who make me say “woof”, boy has Porcello been horrid. Coinciding with his 11.1 IP total is his 11.12 ERA. He’s not a strikeout machine, so his 10 strikeouts don’t bother me…but the 12 walks do! He has the lowest zone% of his career at 42.9%, which has combined with the lowest O-Swing% of his career at 20.8% to total disaster. He claims his struggles aren’t injury-related, but rather mechanical. Perhaps the lack of whiffs points towards pitch tipping. In any case, until Porcello finds a way to right the ship, you need to bench him in deep formats and find someone else in shallow leagues.

The Newcomers

  • Spencer Turnbull, DET (SP81) – Those who grabbed the Turnbull by the horns early on have reaped the early rewards. Through his first 21 innings (4 GS) he has a 3.43 ERA / 1.29 WHIP and a 24:7 K:BB ratio. He’s been touched up by lefties early on, yielding a .352 wOBA and 38.2% hard contact. Opposing managers will undoubtedly latch onto that quickly and stack lefties against him. His four-seam, slider, and curve are all garnering plenty of whiffs though, so even when the blow-up starts come, the strikeouts will be there. He has above-average control, which should help limit those blow-ups, but his ascent up the list will come much slower than his teammate Matt Boyd’s.
  • Luke Weaver, ARZ (SP94) – The Dream Weaver is back! After two unimpressive starts to open the season, it was looking like 2018 Weaver was back. Those were rough matchups though, against the Dodgers and Red Sox lineups. Over his last two starts (SD, @ATL) he has a 17:1 K:BB ratio with just two earned runs over 11.1 IP. His changeup continues to work well, but his increased cutter usage is what is helping him the most. He’s still very much a question mark who I wouldn’t trust against tough opponents, but I’ll let him weave me a wicker basket of Top 100 SP love this week.
  • Tyler Mahle, CIN (SP98) – Just sneaking onto the list we have Tyler Mahle, who could easily be off the list by this time next week. That said, he has made some big changes to his arsenal and deserves to be talked about. Or written about, as it were. Mahle was a disaster in 2018, posting a 4.98 ERA over 112 innings. His minor league track record provided absolutely no value in projections. He was a control artist in the minors with middling strikeout rates, but in Cinci, he walked a ton of batters (4.26 BB/9) while striking out almost a batter per inning (8.84 K/9). So far this year his control looks improved. He’s hitting the zone at a 48.1% clip with a nice 66.7% first-pitch strike rate. He has completely dropped the slider he used 20% of the time last year in lieu of a new-and-improved curveball. It’s so new-and-improved that even the ghost of Billy Mays floated into my bedroom to tell me about it the other night. Sadly, even Billy had to admit that it’s still not a great pitch, netting just 10.45% whiffs. If he can keep the walks in check he can be a deep league streamer, but there still isn’t much upside to glean here.

The Top 100 Starting Pitchers

RankNamePrevious Rank
1Max Scherzer1
2Jacob DeGrom2
3Gerrit Cole4
4Trevor Bauer3
5Justin Verlander6
6Blake Snell7
7Corey Kluber5
8Aaron Nola8
9Patrick Corbin10
10Jose Berrios11
11Carlos Carrasco12
12Noah Syndergaard9
13Luis Castillo14
14Jameson Taillon13
15Zack Wheeler15
16Chris Sale16
17Jack Flaherty17
18James Paxton18
19Stephen Strasburg19
20David Price20
21Shane Bieber21
22German Marquez22
23Chris Archer27
24Madison Bumgarner28
25Masahiro Tanaka25
26Charlie Morton26
27Walker Buehler23
28Zack Greinke24
29Clayton Kershaw29
30Tyler Glasnow35
31Matt Boyd40
32Robbie Ray32
33Chris Paddack33
34Yusei Kikuchi34
35Cole Hamels42
36Kenta Maeda31
37Joe Musgrove72
38Collin McHugh41
39Jose Quintana52
40J.A. Happ37
41Yu Darvish49
42Caleb Smith48
43Marco Gonzales51
44Hyun-Jin RyuNR
45Jon Gray38
46Julio Urias44
47Eduardo Rodriguez46
48Carlos Rodon60
49Mike SorokaNR
50Kyle Hendricks39
51Matt Shoemaker50
52Merrill Kelly55
53Joey Lucchesi54
54Trevor Richards53
55Zach Eflin62
56Michael Pineda56
57Kevin Gausman73
58Kyle Freeland57
59Miles Mikolas30
60Pablo Lopez59
61Derek Holland63
62Jake Arrieta61
63Steven Matz64
64Kyle Gibson65
65Brandon Woodruff66
66Marcus Stroman70
67Jeff Samardzija88
68Sonny Gray94
69Rick Porcello36
70Brad Keller69
71Michael Wacha76
72Trevor Williams79
73Aaron Sanchez80
74CC SabathiaNR
75Ross Stripling74
76Brad PeacockNR
77Domingo German92
78Yonny Chirinos68
79Wade Miley84
80Dereck Rodriguez75
81Spencer TurnbullNR
82Nathan Eovaldi71
83Jordan Zimmermann82
84Ryan Yarbrough86
85Julio Teheran81
86Max FriedNR
87Vince Velasquez87
88Touki ToussaintNR
89Corbin Burnes67
90Zach DaviesNR
91Clay BuchholzNR
92Frankie Montas91
93Mike MinorNR
94Luke WeaverNR
95Nick MargeviciusNR
96Trevor Cahill98
97Reynaldo Lopez78
98Tyler MahleNR
99Trent Thornton90
100Zack Godley85

Fell Off The List

Tyler Skaggs (injury), Sean Newcomb (optioned), Kyle Wright (optioned), Freddy Peralta (injury), Jonathan Loaisiga (optioned), Sandy Alcantara (performance), Eric Lauer (performance), Jhoulys Chacin (performance), Anibal Sanchez (performance), Matt Strahm (performance), Jake Odorizzi (performance).

Nathan Dokken is a member of the FSWA and has had his work featured in numerous books and magazines. He has also appeared on many podcasts and radio shows and hosts the Nasty Cast and Fantrax Dynasty Baseball podcasts. His written work can be found exclusively at Fantrax HQ, and his personal thoughts and opinions can be found on Twitter @NathanDokken.

Fantrax was one of the fastest growing fantasy sites of 2018 and things are only getting better! With multi-team trades, designated commissioner/league managers, and drag/drop easy click methods, Fantrax is sure to excite the serious fantasy sports fan – sign up now for a free year at

  1. Chet says

    I understand injuries and all, but how does Mike Foltynewicz not even crack the top 100?

    1. Nathan Dokken says

      I simply don’t rank injured pitchers. He’ll be well within the top 100 when he returns.

      1. Micah says

        Any idea where you’ll slot Rich Hill into your rankings upon his return?

        1. Nathan Dokken says

          He’ll slot in around SP40-45

Leave A Reply

Your email address will not be published.