2019 Fantrax SuperFlex Dynasty Mock Draft Review

Mock draft season is upon us with analysts and eager drafters crowding the lobbies. Mocks serve a couple of purposes. Drafters get a feel for positional value. The fantasy community gets additional draft data to adjust their own rankings as they see fit. A dynasty mock draft, especially a startup, is a slightly different breed. Actual drafts involve trades using players and/or future draft capital adding complexity. It also creates a level of subjectivity as player and draft capital value can vary. But still, draft results are the best place to start.

If you’re ever invited to a dynasty mock draft, make your picks and execute your own strategy. You should even review your team for roster construction and short-term approaches. But, the biggest advantage is in the chat. Analysts discuss their approach, trades they could have made, and alternative routes. They can help shape your own strategy for future drafts. Fantrax was able to bring together a solid group of analysts to provide such an example.

It’s always fantasy time at Fantrax.com! You can start a Fantasy Football League 364 days a year! Looking for a place to host your league? Check out the Fantrax Fantasy Football Commissioner. Or if you’re looking to win real cash prizes you might want to enter one of their Classic Draft Contests. And when you’re getting ready for your league head on over to the Fantrax Mock Draft Lobby to get your draft on!

Dynasty Mock Draft Participants

League setup and rules were as follows:

• Scoring: Superflex, PPR
• League: 20 rounds, No trades

Round 1

A lesson in league etiquette: Make sure the entire league knows the scoring settings before the draft starts. The. Entire. League.

It explains the slight dip in Mahomes’ ADP, but the first round primarily followed ADP. All except Connor at 10^th overall. Typically selected as RB11, an RB6 selection was something of a surprise. Aggressive picks like this create pockets of value for the managers that follow as the draft is restructured. With the pick occurring towards the end of the round, the value couldn’t be realized until the next set of picks.

Round 2

Todd Gurley’s health has been a constant point of contention across the fantasy community. It’s caused his cost to become more subjective than whatever data can be uncovered regarding draft price. Hence, the slight disappointment at his selection here in the mock draft:

“My least favorite pick was taking Todd Gurley at 2.01. That seemed like a value at the time, but now I see that he’s dropping even further. His appropriate price is probably in the third round at this point. If I had it to do over again, especially if I had realized this was SF from the start, I would have taken a QB there or possibly Travis Kelce.” – Kevin Zatloukal (@kczat)

Draft strategy regarding quarterbacks also created some value for those leveraging the Superflex format:

“Deshaun Watson at 19 overall by @DynastyOuthouse. In a Superflex league, it’s rare that so many people opted to wait on quarterbacks. Only Patrick Mahomes was drafted in the first round (coincidentally, also by @DynastyOuthouse). He absolutely got a steal by locking up two fantasy QBs that should be battling for the overall top spot for the next decade.” – Tyler Buecher (@TylerBuecher)

Round 3

The third round of the mock is still packed with elite talent at all positions allowing drafters to find both value and players they’re rooting for in 2019.

“Nearly [all of my picks] looked like a value by 4for4’s rankings. If I had to pick two, though, I would say Josh Jacobs and Kyler Murray in rounds 3 and 4 are my favorite picks.”  – Kevin Zatloukal (@kczat)

“My third round pick is one that I wasn’t expecting to make — Travis Kelce at No. 27 overall — but when you get a chance to land a premier talent that dominates their position at a value, you have to adjust. Kelce should continue to be a top-five dynasty tight end for several more years in that electric offense.” – Tyler Buecher (@TylerBuecher)

The third round is also where different draft strategies can be executed.

“I would’ve traded out my third round pick (A.J. Green) to try and get two picks in the 4-7th rounds. I like most of the WRs drafted in that territory and would’ve rather had an extra pick. – Brandon Niles (@2guysbrandon)”

Round 4

Superflex changes the supply and demand effect normally observed in standard formats. It allows for different approaches that hinge more on personal preference than FOMO. That started to show here in the 4^th round of the mock draft.

“I typically let the other teams’ choices of quarterbacks dictate when I’m going to start pulling the trigger on my own QB slot in Superflex leagues. Once the first seven QBs were gone, I decided it would behoove me to snatch up my quarterbacks near the end of the 4th (Wentz)/beginning of the 5th (Winston). I would have preferred to wait longer but didn’t want to pick from the QB15-QB20 range at the end of the 6th.” – Justin Edwards (@Justin_Redwards)

Round 5

Mid-round quarterbacks, volume-driven running backs, and receivers in positive situations filled the 5^th round of the dynasty mock draft. With drafters looking to either acquire their first or second quarterback, it presents a trade opportunity for savvy owners.

“…I’m also a big proponent of trading super early picks for multiple 3rd/4th/5th rounders if I can find someone who really really wants their QB1 at the 1st/2nd turn.” – Justin Edwards (@Justin_Redwards)

“Being near the turn in the 5th I felt like at that point a QB run could happen soon so with Matt Ryan being the QB9, I was ok with getting him there having taken two running backs and two wide receivers previously. I could have waited another round on quarterback but Ryan I felt gave me a good mix of longevity & upside with that pick.” – Derek Brown (@DBro_FF)

A similar trading process can be applied to some of the talent projected to make an impact in 2019.

“Players that possess immense upside both talent and volume wise are always ones that I’m willing to aggressively move up for in drafts. After my selection of Ryan in the 5th, I would have moved back up to snag David Montgomery who went two picks later who I honestly nearly took with my Ryan selection.” – Derek Brown (@DBro_FF)

Round 6

As quarterbacks are pushed up, high-value players can be found as late as the 6^th round in most mock drafts. A few drafters were able to mine the player pool for upside. From the drafters:

“I think in this format, getting Edelman in the sixth was good value.” – Brandon Niles (@2guysbrandon)

“Players I would have moved up to draft include Calvin Ridley at 6.02 and Tyler Lockett at 6.09.” – Derek Brown (@DBro_FF)

By the end of the round, 17 quarterbacks had been drafted with nearly half the league already having two on their roster. Only one team had not yet drafted a quarterback. This strategy is prominent amongst dynasty drafters looking to leverage the desire for youth throughout their league. Even with so many quarterbacks taken off the board in this mock draft, there was still plenty to be had later.

Round 7

Brandon Niles gets his guy. Philip Rivers. Averaged over 4,000 yards and 30 touchdowns the past 6 years. The only issue is his contract situation. He’s set to be an Unrestricted Free Agent in 2020, but the team hasn’t made any moves to suggest a replacement is waiting in the wings. Regardless, he presents a value opportunity at such a low draft cost. The same could be said for Allen Robinson by looking at the receivers drafted around him. At nearly 26, he’s the primary receiver in an offensive constantly looking to maximizing its talent. Few players of his archetype can be found at such a cost.

Round 8

Nearly 30 running backs were selected in the first 7 rounds of this dynasty mock draft with almost a clear tier drop in talent as the 8^th round began. Narrative and paths to touches become a greater part of the draft. Value becomes more subjective and flags begin to be planted. Christian Kirk has quickly become one of the offseason’ s greatest commodities. He saw the second greatest target share in the offense while operating both out of the slot and on the outside. Now, with Kliff Kingsbury and Kyler Murray, all eyes are on Arizona.

Round 9

Eight teams had drafted two quarterbacks by the start of the 9^th round of the mock. Those still looking to fill their Superflex spot with another quarterback had to make some tough decisions for their squad to remain competitive.

“I took my second quarterback sooner than I planned. Even in a SuperFlex, I expected the third-tier guys to be available in the 10th round and beyond, but by the time the ninth round rolled around, Nick Foles was one of the few solidified starters remaining on the board. Guys like Darnold, Trubisky, and Lamar Jackson were taken right before I was planning to grab them. I ended up grabbing a couple of late-round long-term flyers in Mason Rudolph and Jared Stidham to try and compensate.” – Brandon Niles (@2guysbrandon)

Others were still looking at collecting value attempting to simulate trade strategies if this were an actual startup draft.

“With my squad in “win-now” mode, I would’ve loved to have found a way to trade back in the ninth round. I ended up selecting Ben Roethlisberger as my QB3 as I thought he was the end of a QB tier, but with Cam Newton and Lamar Jackson already on my squad, I would’ve preferred to trade back and select an additional RB/WR to help with weekly flex plays.” – Tyler Buecher (@TylerBuecher)

Round 10

Matt Stafford at QB26 had to be the value pick of the mock draft. Detroit fell to 14^th in Pass to Run ratio after being Top 10 the previous 4 seasons. Their draft moves indicate a run-first offensive philosophy, but they still have viable weapons at receiver and a quarterback that’s been known to throw the ball. Surprised a few other folks in the draft.

“I had my eye on Stafford as he fell but got sniped the pick before, I likely would have traded up nearly six picks to grab him at the beginning of the 10th and it probably wouldn’t have cost me much.”

“But, in all seriousness, Matt Stafford as the QB26 at 10.07 by Dynasty Outhouse.” – Justin Edwards (@Justin_Redwards)

Round 11

The Superflex format emphasizes the need for two quarterbacks to leverage the scoring system. With bye weeks and projected weekly upside, a third might be needed. Four were selected in the 11^th round of the mock, but one had some particular upside.

“Having Josh Rosen available in the 11th round in a Superflex draft was immense value. His value has nowhere to go but up. Considering this was a player that was the second-ranked quarterback for many in last year’s draft class I could not pass him up as my QB3.”  – Derek Brown (@DBro_FF)

Round 12

The early rounds of a dynasty mock draft are filled with receiver archetypes typically described as ‘consistent’. But logical roster construction points to having a boom-bust player with week winning potential. Players in this category are always useful, but the risk drives their price down. That describes most of the players drafted here in the 12^th. And, as always, there are plenty of trade targets present for many owners looking to supplement their rosters.

“With 12th & 13th (12.11/13.02) picks, I felt the upside at that point was too much to pass with Marquez Valdes-Scantling and Robert Foster remaining. Their athletic profiles, as well as flashes in their rookie seasons, could both land them in the top 24 wide receivers this season.” – Derek Brown (@DBro_FF)

Round 13

It’s somewhat surprising that after finishing the season as RB26, with extrapolated stats having him at over 1000 yards, and multiple RB1 weeks, Matt Breida falls into the 13^th round or later in most mock drafts. The crowded backfield with Tevin Coleman added and Jerrick McKinnon returning from injury clouds the situation, but Breida has the most experience in Shanahan’s system. Breida comes with his own injury concerns, but at 24 years old, he’s worth reaching on at this cost.

Round 14

With most primary positions filled, supplemental picks were being made to fill out rosters in this mock. Almost half of the draft picks were tight ends (despite two timeouts) signaling the lack of demand for the position. My own squad lacked wide receivers and, looking back on it, I’d have preferred any of the receivers selected after my pick at 14.02. Even with Duke Johnson’s untold upside, positional demand in a PPR league would benefit rosters with a better compilation of receivers. I’d have to look at the position during the next couple of rounds.

Round 15

Kenny Stills went 4 picks before my selection in the 15^th round of this dynasty mock draft. The Fitzpatrick-Jackson connection in Tampa Bay easily translates to how Stills is deployed making him an ideal selection in every fantasy format. The Jets, like Miami, also project to be one of the bottom offenses in the league, but Crowder walks into a healthy share of targets as the team’s primary slot receiver. Identified as a viable trade-up target by Derek Brown, the volume of targets presented to Crowder make him an ideal target in the 15^th round.

Round 16

The 16^th round of the mock played host to long shots along with short-term gains. I was still looking to add to my wide receiver corps and Albert Wilson has been a community favorite for a couple of seasons. In his limited roles, his athleticism has proven useful on the field and in the boxscore. Immediately after my pick, we have an investment that will take years to pay off. Regardless of how long Tom Brady plays, New England’s backup QB is always alluring to both NFL and fantasy GMs. There’s no telling how long Tom Brady will actually play so making the acquisition as Brandon’s QB4 reduces the risk given the available talent on the board.

Other short-term investments include Joe Flacco, DeSean Jackson, Jimmy Graham, and Adrian Peterson. Players that boast utility in 2019, but carry serious doubt in their availability past the upcoming season due to contract, age, or both.

Round 17

I’ve tried to draft Dexter Williams in almost every mock, startup, or rookie draft. He’s the perfect complement to Aaron Jones and has an easy path to outshining Jamaal Williams to take the backup role in a high-powered offense.

Dart throws highlighted the 17^th round of our dynasty mock draft. Trey Quinn has received some offseason buzz due to the uncertainty surrounding the wide receiver corps in Washington and his slot usage. The Damien Williams-Carlos Hyde debate continues across almost every fantasy social platform. Mike Davis’ role is somewhat nebulous with David Montgomery being drafted in the early rounds. In mock drafts, it’s difficult to judge value with so many teams willing to acquire players well before their ADP. It also causes some drafters to reach before they necessarily needed to:

“I also regret a couple of my later picks: taking Jack Doyle over Darren Waller and Jalen Hurd over Justin Watson. But those are all dart throws anyway.” – Kevin Zatloukal (@kczat)

Round 18

It could be a coincidence or it could be an indication of their offense, but four players from Washington were selected in this round of the mock. Three were rookies making them low-risk investments with adequate upside especially in the case of McLaurin who will continue to grow with his college quarterback. Bryce Love will (hopefully) become a complement to Derrius Guice once Adrian Peterson retires.

But I was looking for another quarterback. The Wilson-Carr duo doesn’t inspire much confidence even with Russ’ contract and Antonio Brown’s move to Oakland. Manning presents temporary value that should at least open the 2019 season. In retrospect, a long-term/upside pick earlier (e.g. Drew Lock) would have been better to round out the squad, but Manning was the best available at the time.

Round 19

The last two rounds of this dynasty mock draft and a couple of interesting late-round rookie picks came off the board. Leonard Fournette is known for a few things. First, being the primary rusher on a run-first offense with a strong defense. After that, it’s injuries, suspensions, and off the field issues. That’s what makes Ryquell Armstead an interesting selection for the Jaguars and placed him on many dynasty owner’s late-round lists.

The same goes for Jalen Hurd. San Francisco tends to feature multiple receivers with relative target share on a week to week basis. He’s not Deebo Samuel or Dante Pettis, but has the appeal of a big-body target that could be used in the red zone. I wanted to piece of the Arizona offense and looked to round out my tight end squad with Ricky Seals-Jones. He’s not guaranteed volume, but any cheap asset in an Air Raid system should be worth a late-round dart throw.

Round 20

Tony Pollard could become a high-value draft target for more than just dynasty owners. He’s already been spotted working out with the first offense in training camp and there’s been no official word on Ezekiel Elliot after his latest run-in with law enforcement. Its possible Pollard becomes an in-game complement giving him some change-of-pace value with the athleticism for a greater workload. His cost in this mock draft makes him an easy value and his involvement in the offense should be monitored throughout the offseason.

Did you enjoy this SuperFlex Dynasty Mock Draft? For more great rankings, sleepers, and analysis check out the 2019 Fantrax Fantasy Football Draft Kit.

Chris Allen comes from an analytical background, leveraging his data skills with his multiple years of experience across different formats (e.g. seasonal redraft, DFS, MFL10). His primary focus has been the analysis of weather effects and its impact on games, player output variance, and the validity of the associated narratives. Chris’ writings have been featured on multiple websites including Fantrax, 4for4, and, most recently, Sports Illustrated. Chris can also be heard as co-host on the Dynasty Owners Manual podcast and is a member of the FSWA.

Fantrax was one of the fastest growing fantasy sites of 2018 and things are booming in 2019. With multi-team trades, designated commissioner/league managers, and drag/drop easy click methods, Fantrax is sure to excite the serious fantasy sports fan – sign up now for a free year at Fantrax.com.