2021 Consensus Top-100 Fantasy Baseball Starting Pitcher Rankings

That’s right, it’s finally Fantasy Baseball draft season! While some of us degenerates were drafting back in October and November, January is the first month where fantasy baseball drafts really kick into high gear. We here at FantraxHQ have been pumping out a ton of great content all offseason long and now are diving head-first into our 2021 Fantrax Fantasy Baseball Draft Kit. A big part of any draft kit is rankings, and we’re starting our staff consensus rankings for 2021 with our fantasy baseball starting pitcher rankings.

Below you’ll find the consensus rankings that eight of our MLB writers were involved in. Those being Eric Cross, Chris Clegg, Jake Devereaux, Justin Johnson, Jorge Montanez, David Mendelson, Nic Civale, and Dave Swan. Each writer provided anywhere from 100-150 pitchers so we could create our consensus top-100.

The 2021 pitcher landscape is very exciting. You see a discernable top tier of three names, and then tier two is a hot mess. In a good way though. Capitalizing on pitching is more important now than ever before, so hopefully, these rankings can help guide you in the right direction for all of your drafts. Enjoy!

What?! Your league is not planning on using Fantrax? Inconceivable! Check out everything Fantrax has to offer and I’m sure you’ll come around to our way of thinking.

2021 Fantasy Baseball Starting Pitcher Rankings

Rank	Player	Eric	Chris	Mendy	Jorge	Justin	Jake	Dave	Nic
1	Jacob deGrom	1	1	2	1	1	2	2	1
2	Gerrit Cole	3	2	1	3	2	3	1	3
3	Shane Bieber	2	3	3	2	3	1	3	2
4	Trevor Bauer	4	5	9	5	4	8	4	7
5	Luis Castillo	9	4	6	4	5	9	8	9
6	Yu Darvish	5	8	8	7	8	6	9	4
7	Aaron Nola	6	7	7	6	11	7	7	6
8	Walker Buehler	7	6	5	8	10	5	5	12
9	Lucas Giolito	8	9	4	10	7	4	6	10
10	Max Scherzer	10	10	13	13	13	11	10	5
11	Clayton Kershaw	11	12	16	11	9	12	12	8
12	Brandon Woodruff	14	13	11	9	6	10	13	15
13	Zac Gallen	13	14	12	15	12	14	14	11
14	Jack Flaherty	12	11	10	12	20	15	11	14
15	Blake Snell	15	15	15	16	18	16	17	17
16	Kenta Maeda	17	17	17	18	15	19	15	13
17	Sonny Gray	18	16	14	14	16	21	20	19
18	Lance Lynn	20	18	20	22	14	17	24	16
19	Max Fried	16	21	21	23	19	13	25	23
20	Tyler Glasnow	21	20	22	19	25	28	16	18
21	Corbin Burnes	19	22	23	20	21	23	19	29
22	Zach Plesac	23	28	19	17	17	20	21	32
23	Carlos Carrasco	22	19	25	21	26	34	18	20
24	Hyun jin Ryu	24	25	33	24	23	26	27	21
25	Kyle Hendricks	25	27	31	25	24	32	30	22
26	Dinelson Lamet	26	39	40	29	22	29	22	24
27	Zack Wheeler	33	26	24	30	27	41	31	25
28	Jesus Luzardo	28	30	36	32	30	18	28	37
29	Jose Berrios	31	24	30	28	28	33	37	43
30	Stephen Strasburg	30	29	18	31	31	64	26	27
31	Dylan Bundy	38	23	41	26	32	24	34	47
32	Pablo Lopez	37	31	34	33	36	37	29	36
33	Zack Greinke	32	40	26	38	44	25	35	34
34	Framber Valdez	34	36	27	34	40	42	23	48
35	Lance McCullers	39	32	29	36	42	38	33	41
36	Sixto Sanchez	27	37	51	39	29	22	49	40
37	Chris Paddack	36	34	35	40	38	46	39	30
38	Charlie Morton	42	45	28	46	33	47	38	26
39	Ian Anderson	29	44	47	35	41	27	42	49
40	Patrick Corbin	41	38	52	42	34	31	51	31
41	Julio Urias	40	41	32	45	37	50	41	39
42	Kevin Gausman	43	52	39	27	43	40	32	54
43	Sandy Alcantara	35	35	43	37	39	73	40	35
44	Aaron Civale	45	43	37	47	55	43	43	28
45	Frankie Montas	46	33	38	41	53	51	50	38
46	Mike Soroka	44	42	67	44	35	35	62	42
47	Dustin May	53	46	58	50	50	30	63	53
48	Tony Gonsolin	48	54	46	56	54	49	47	NR
49	German Marquez	51	50	49	49	48	53	52	58
50	Tyler Mahle	55	48	42	51	59	79	44	50
51	Joe Musgrove	47	61	59	43	51	69	46	55
52	David Price	59	56	45	54	49	63	60	46
53	Marcus Stroman	80	49	54	55	46	48	45	64
54	Dallas Keuchel	56	57	48	61	45	52	68	60
55	Chris Sale	67	64	44	71	63	36	58	45
56	Andrew Heaney	54	55	56	57	60	45	36	88
57	Chris Bassitt	57	47	70	48	47	72	61	65
58	Marco Gonzales	60	51	71	52	57	44	48	97
59	John Means	72	53	53	53	69	82	59	44
60	Corey Kluber	52	58	64	78	80	66	76	33
61	Triston McKenzie	49	80	63	66	65	55	74	57
62	Eduardo Rodriguez	61	62	55	64	74	59	70	66
63	James Paxton	64	59	62	77	66	83	66	63
64	Brady Singer	58	67	72	72	58	87	56	74
65	Jose Urquidy	74	66	81	60	68	85	57	62
66	Jordan Montgomery	89	65	50	58	81	96	55	59
67	Zach Eflin	70	60	66	62	56	100	54	89
68	Cristian Javier	50	72	77	68	52	103	64	72
69	Dane Dunning	68	70	75	59	75	70	88	69
70	Elieser Hernandez	73	71	NR	65	79	61	NR	83
71	Zach Davies	69	73	65	69	61	57	84	106
72	Jameson Taillon	104	63	68	63	73	68	73	NR
73	Masahiro Tanaka	78	76	89	82	90	65	53	56
74	Shohei Ohtani	63	79	NR	81	72	NR	NR	NR
75	Noah Syndergaard	65	94	98	76	71	56	75	61
76	Michael Kopech	77	103	57	NR	64	76	80	79
77	Kwang Hyun Kim	71	83	83	100	70	67	78	68
78	Justus Sheffield	85	81	74	86	67	84	65	87
79	Matthew Boyd	91	68	76	84	NR	80	71	82
80	Nate Pearson	62	102	NR	67	83	86	81	NR
81	Drew Smyly	82	74	73	75	89	89	82	81
82	Luis Severino	88	95	96	97	78	58	77	71
83	MacKenzie Gore	66	147	60	73	91	54	87	NR
84	Tarik Skubal	79	97	94	98	62	60	89	85
85	Nathan Eovaldi	86	87	61	88	82	78	67	115
86	Tomoyuki Sugano	115	108	NR	NR	76	39	NR	NR
87	Mitch Keller	95	88	92	87	96	62	86	73
88	Ryan Yarbrough	101	119	69	74	86	71	85	92
89	Casey Mize	75	96	78	80	99	75	107	NR
90	Deivi Garcia	90	82	85	95	NR	105	NR	67
91	Yusei Kikuchi	110	98	NR	70	87	88	69	95
92	Griffin Canning	87	92	91	101	88	81	95	77
93	Michael Pineda	76	89	NR	109	97	74	83	98
94	Sean Manaea	84	77	100	92	NR	93	79	102
95	Seth Lugo	83	NR	90	NR	NR	101	NR	93
96	Matt Manning	92	NR	NR	NR	92	NR	NR	NR
97	Mike Minor	120	69	NR	85	NR	112	97	70
98	Spencer Howard	81	93	97	99	77	77	104	110
99	Jake Odorizzi	103	78	NR	91	95	91	100	90
100	Caleb Smith	93	86	82	94	NR	117	93	91

Did you find these consensus rankings useful? For more great rankings, strategy, and analysis check out the 2021 FantraxHQ Fantasy Baseball Draft Kit. We’ll be adding more content from now right up until Opening Day!

Fantrax was one of the fastest-growing fantasy sites of 2020 and we’re not stopping now. With multi-team trades, designated commissioner/league managers, and drag/drop easy click methods, Fantrax is sure to excite the serious fantasy sports fan – sign up now for a free year at Fantrax.com.

2020 Fantasy EPL Draft Kit

2021 Consensus Top-100 Fantasy Baseball Starting Pitcher Rankings

2021 Fantasy Baseball Starting Pitcher Rankings

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

2020 Fantasy EPL Draft Kit

2021 Consensus Top-100 Fantasy Baseball Starting Pitcher Rankings

2021 Fantasy Baseball Starting Pitcher Rankings

Reader Interactions

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Footer