The Home of Fantasy Sports Analysis

Could Trevor Lawrence be a Top Fantasy Quarterback in 2021?

Trevor Lawrence, the first overall pick in the 2021 NFL Draft, signed his four-year $36.8 million rookie deal early Monday morning.  He is now green-lit for his first professional training camp as the projected starting quarterback for the Jacksonville Jaguars.  While Lawrence was the top pick in the NFL draft, there is no guarantee that he will finish as a top fantasy quarterback in 2021.

Say what?! Your fantasy football league wasn’t hosted on Fantrax last season? Unthinkable! Check out all the features Fantrax has to offer, and we think you’ll be singing a different tune for next season.

Top Pick Doesn’t Always Mean Top Production

Looking back at every NFL draft since 2010, a quarterback was selected with the first overall pick eight times.  Here is how each quarterback taken with the top pick in those drafts finished, on a points per game basis, in fantasy football their rookie season:

2010- Sam Bradford (St. Louis Rams): 16.2 points per game / 26th overall

2011- Cam Newton (Carolina Panthers): 27.6 ppg / 4th

2012*- Andrew Luck (Indianapolis Colts): 22.9 ppg / 9th

*Robert Griffin III (2nd overall pick, Washington’s Team): 24.4 ppg / 5th

2015- Jameis Winston (Tampa Bay Buccaneers): 21.7 ppg / 18th

2016**- Jared Goff (7 games, Los Angeles Rams): 11.7 ppg / 41st 

**Carson Wentz (2nd overall pick, 16 games with Philadelphia Eagles): 17.5 ppg / 27th

2018- Baker Mayfield (Cleveland Browns): 22.0 ppg / 15th

2019- Kyler Murray (Arizona Cardinals): 21.5 ppg / 13th

2020- Joe Burrow (10 games, Cincinnati Bengals): 21.9/ 16th

As you can see, only two of these quarterbacks finished as a top fantasy quarterback, specifically in the top-10, in their rookie season: Cam Newton and Andrew Luck in 2011 and 2012.

Newton scored 14 rushing touchdowns as a rookie, which is still an NFL record at the quarterback position.  Luck scored the third-most rushing touchdowns as a quarterback in 2012, but second overall pick that season, Robert Griffin III, finished ahead of him.  RGIII even played in one less game, totaling 1,100+ fewer passing yards, but had a ridiculous 118 carries for 833 yards and 7 rushing touchdowns.

Averaging 77 carries per season at Clemson, with 17 scores on the ground his final two years, Lawrence isn’t a stranger to using his legs.  It’s hard to imagine, however, he sees nearly that many carries, specifically designed runs, and especially for touchdowns, his rookie season.

The Jacksonville backfield consists of college teammate, rookie Travis Etienne, 2020 breakout, James Robinson, and steady veteran, Carlos Hyde.  Without production on the ground, Lawrence is going to have to be nearly flawless in the passing game to finish as a top fantasy quarterback ahead of those that do tack on valuable fantasy rushing points.

Lawrence currently has an Average Draft Position of approximately QB14.  Historically speaking, as seen above, that seems appropriate given his potential as a pro.  The top-3 Jaguars pass catchers, D.J. Chark, Jr., Marvin Jones Jr., and Laviska Shenault carry pre-training camp ADPs of about WR30, WR47, and WR48 respectively.  I would rather bet on Trevor Lawrence’s ability by selecting one of those receivers at their current ADPs than counting on him as my starter in Week 1.

It may be wise to roster Lawrence this year, just don’t reach for him too early expecting him to finish as a top fantasy quarterback his rookie season.  There are more proven quarterbacks on better rosters, with more experience, and that utilize their rushing ability that I would select before him.  He is without a doubt the top rookie fantasy quarterback in dynasty formats, but his collegiate success may not carry over immediately into Jacksonville in 2021.

Fantasy Leagues on Fantrax Fantasy Basketball

Fantrax was one of the fastest-growing fantasy sites of 2020, and we’re not letting our foot off the pedal now! With multi-team trades, designated commissioner/league managers, and drag/drop easy click methods, Fantrax is sure to excite the serious fantasy sports fan – sign up now for a free year at

Leave A Reply

Your email address will not be published.