2023 Consensus Fantasy Baseball Outfield Rankings

Spring has sprung! Pitchers and catchers report this week and Spring Training games are not very far away. With that of course comes a nice normal preseason of fantasy baseball draft prep. For you, that means reading and listening to as much content as possible. For the FantraxHQ staff, it means flushing out their rankings and getting ready for the inevitable onslaught of criticism that will come their way. Rankings MLB players is not easy and with a player pool hundreds deep, the differences between players can get very narrow. Remember this as you peruse or consensus outfield rankings for 2023 fantasy baseball.

The season is not here yet, but why not get a head start and jump in a Fantrax Classic Draft contest? Get a jump on the season with a Best Ball league or maybe a Draft and Hold. Or put some green on the line with a new season-long league to try and conquer. There’s no better time than now to get your baseball on!

The 2023 Outfield Pool

We’ve become accustomed to talking about how the outfield is so deep. Is it really? Sure there’s an incredibly talented top 10 and you can find usable players pretty late, but the middle tiers seem to blend together more than usual this year and the questions begin just after that top tier. You’ll see in the outfield rankings below, that there is a lot of disagreement throughout that big middle grouping. A lot of leagues are going to be won and lost based on decisions on these outfielders during the middle and late rounds of fantasy baseball drafts.

2023 Fantasy Baseball Outfield Rankings

Meet the Analysts: | MH = Matt Heckman | LA = Lauren Auerbach | TT = Taylor Tarter | DF = Dave Funnell | TB = Tyler Bowen | EF = Ed Fingerhut

Cons. Rnk	Player	MH	LA	TT	DF	TB	EF
1	Ronald Acuna Jr.	3	1	2	1	1	2
2	Aaron Judge	1	3	1	2	3	3
3	Julio Rodriguez	5	4	3	3	4	1
4	Yordan Alvarez	2	6	7	6	2	5
5	Kyle Tucker	6	2	4	4	7	6
6	Juan Soto	7	7	6	5	5	4
7	Mookie Betts	4	8	8	7	8	7
8	Fernando Tatis Jr.	11	5	5	9	6	10
9	Mike Trout	8	9	9	8	9	9
10	Michael Harris II	13	10	10	11	10	8
11	Randy Arozarena	12	11	11	10	12	12
12	Adolis Garcia	10	12	12	13	15	13
13	Kyle Schwarber	9	13	16	15	13	11
14	Luis Robert	21	17	13	12	11	15
15	Cedric Mullins II	22	14	15	14	19	14
16	George Springer	23	19	17	17	22	17
17	Bryan Reynolds	15	27	29	16	17	18
18	Teoscar Hernandez	25	15	20	18	16	29
19	Corbin Carroll	18	22	21	23	18	23
20	Byron Buxton	16	26	33	22	14	16
21	Starling Marte	29	20	14	21	23	22
22	Daulton Varsho	31	16	19	20	21	25
23	Tyler O'Neill	19	24	18	31	28	19
24	Eloy Jimenez	30	28	22	19	20	24
25	Seiya Suzuki	17	18	27	24	29	33
26	Christian Yelich	24	29	24	25	33	20
27	Anthony Santander	20	25	26	28	34	27
28	Taylor Ward	14	32	28	29	27	35
29	Steven Kwan	28	23	25	27	25	41
30	Giancarlo Stanton	35	35	31	36	24	21
31	Jake McCarthy	52	21	23	32	30	30
32	Kris Bryant	34	30	41	26	26	38
33	Ian Happ	26	34	34	33	38	34
34	Hunter Renfroe	27	33	32	35	41	37
35	Nick Castellanos	42	31	30	30	37	39
36	Andrew Vaughn	38	47	38	34	32	36
37	Brandon Nimmo	36	52	44	37	35	26
38	Riley Greene	33	40	53	43	36	43
39	Lars Nootbaar	32	42	45	47	39	54
40	Alex Verdugo	40	38	48	42	51	42
41	Jeff McNeil	46	50	51	39	46	32
42	MJ Melendez	48	62	35	38	31	60
43	Cody Bellinger	45	51	46	48	48	40
44	Seth Brown	47	39	40	50	50	53
45	Harrison Bader	41	43	36	44	57	64
46	Oscar Gonzalez	59	63	43	41	52	28
47	Mitch Haniger	54	55	47	40	62	31
48	Andrew Benintendi	43	37	64	46	61	50
49	Joc Pederson	37	57	58	49	56	49
50	Ramon Laureano	53	53	56	51	44	51
50	Joey Meneses	57	41	39	53	72	46
50	Gavin Lux	58	44	55	57	49	45
53	Lourdes Gurriel Jr.	60	45	52	52	53	52
54	Masataka Yoshida	50	54	49	64	42	57
55	Whit Merrifield	74	46	42	45	94	44
56	Austin Hays	73	59	59	54	55	48
57	Michael Conforto	55	66	66	55	54	55
58	Trey Mancini	44	60	62	60	66	63
59	Christopher Morel	76	80	37	62	45	62
60	Jesse Winker	63	69	70	61	40	61
61	Wil Myers	56	36	50	86	58	86
62	Bryan De La Cruz	51	89	61	58	64	59
63	Brandon Marsh	39	84	72	63	47	84
64	Randal Grichuk	91	48	63	56	79	56
65	Manuel Margot	65	58	81	67	60	67
66	Charlie Blackmon	84	56	77	59	68	58
67	Austin Meadows	67	95	69	65	43	66
68	Chris Taylor	78	78	54	66	70	69
69	Trent Grisham	61	81	93	69	80	65
70	Alex Kirilloff	68	94	78	74	63	77
71	Jake Fraley	96	68	57	72	86	76
72	Esteury Ruiz	NR	49	67	90	65	47
73	Dylan Carlson	80	77	87	70	71	85
74	Jorge Soler	85	76	80	76	87	68
75	Mark Canha	87	67	88	75	88	75
76	Garrett Mitchell	83	85	94	84	67	71
77	Brendan Donovan	75	97	74	85	84	70
78	Max Kepler	62	75	89	100	69	92
79	Jarred Kelenic	70	99	97	73	76	73
80	Andrew McCutchen	71	64	85	96	85	95
81	Lane Thomas	66	72	60	71	81	NR
82	Nick Gordon	100	86	75	78	75	87
83	Mike Yastrzemski	49	65	NR	82	78	82
83	Oswaldo Cabrera	90	91	92	68	93	72
85	Jose Siri	94	86	99	77	83	74
86	Juan Yepez	92	100	79	87	82	78
87	Tommy Pham	88	79	96	80	98	80
88	Michael Brantley	79	83	NR	79	59	79
89	Marcell Ozuna	97	96	68	83	NR	83
90	Kike Hernandez	NR	93	71	88	92	88
91	Oscar Colas	86	90	90	98	73	NR
92	Edward Olivares	69	70	76	99	NR	NR
93	Avisail Garcia	NR	92	65	81	NR	81
94	AJ Pollock	82	79	84	NR	NR	100
95	Leody Taveras	NR	73	83	93	97	NR
96	TJ Friedl	93	87	82	89	NR	NR
97	Kerry Carpenter	NR	90	91	91	NR	90
98	Adam Duvall	81	61	NR	NR	77	NR
99	Bubba Thompson	101	NR	NR	92	89	91
100	Myles Straw	NR	88	NR	94	100	93
101	Tyrone Taylor	NR	74	86	NR	96	NR
102	Joey Gallo	98	NR	NR	NR	91	89
103	Jurickson Profar	NR	98	NR	95	NR	94
104	Will Brennan	95	NR	NR	NR	74	NR
105	Harold Ramirez	NR	82	NR	NR	95	NR
106	Alek Thomas	99	NR	NR	NR	90	NR
107	Tony Kemp	NR	96	NR	97	NR	NR
108	Matt Vierling	64	NR	NR	NR	NR	NR
109	Dylan Moore	72	NR	NR	NR	NR	NR
110	Tyler Gentry	77	NR	NR	NR	NR	NR
111	Sal Frelick	89	NR	NR	NR	NR	NR
112	Chas McCormick	NR	NR	95	NR	NR	NR
113	Yonathan Daza	NR	NR	NR	NR	NR	96
114	Drew Waters	NR	NR	NR	NR	NR	97
115	Trayce Thompson	NR	NR	NR	NR	NR	98
115	Akil Baddoo	NR	NR	98	NR	NR	NR
117	Will Benson	NR	NR	NR	NR	NR	99

Got a take on our outfield rankings? Let us know about it in the comments below. For more great analysis check out the 2023 FantraxHQ Fantasy Baseball Draft Kit!