The Home of Fantasy Sports Analysis

Starting Pitcher Barometer, Week 1: Taylor, Widener Of Eyes

Gather ’round, ye lads and lasses. Today marks the return of the Starting Pitcher Barometer! I’ve settled into my old comfortable leather chair in front of the fireplace here in this creaky old house. As the fire crackles and you wonder why the eyes keep moving in the paintings on the wall in this dimly lit study, I encourage you not to worry about it. Let’s just focus on baseball and how the starting pitcher rankings are taking form.

Every week I’ll be ranking the top 100 starting pitcher rankings for the rest of the season. I’ll leave off the injured starters unless they’re slated to return the coming week. In every ensuing week, I’ll list the previous week’s ranking. The biggest risers and fallers will earn their own dedicated blurb so as to explain the movement. New additions to the list will earn a blurb as well.

For this first full week of the season, I’ll go over some of the notable performances so far. Is there a reason for panic, or would that be an overreaction after just one start? We shall discuss. Yes, that suit of armor in the corner may have just moved a little bit. He does that sometimes, settle down. Where’s my Great Dane?


What?! Your fantasy baseball league is not using Fantrax? Inconceivable! Check out everything Fantrax has to offer and I’m sure you’ll come around to our way of thinking.


The Starting Pitcher Barometer

Luis Castillo, CIN (3.1 IP, 8 H, 10 R (8 ER), 2 BB, 0 K)

Without a doubt, the most terrifying start thus far belongs to Luis Castillo. He was absolutely annihilated. He didn’t even record a strikeout, so this entire start was just a giant torpedo into the side of the submarine that is your fantasy season. His velocity was also way down – nearly 3 MPH from last year.

Castillo velo chart

That’s just about as startling as walking in on your parents playing Twister in the nude. There is some room for optimism, though, so don’t throw your computer away just yet. Namely, the game-time temperature was 37 degrees. There was also a 16 MPH wind, and even some light flurries (although that isn’t as distracting as light furries). That could have certainly impacted his velo.

There was also some horrible defense behind him, although that’s something that may not improve. All in all, this is a start to throw out the window. He does debut on the list at SP16, which is few spots lower than he would have if these rankings came out a week ago. I wouldn’t be surprised if his FB sat more around the 95-96 MPH range than the 97.5 MPH we saw last year. However, in 2018 when he sat 95.8 MPH, he put up his worst season to date (4.30 ERA, 8.75 K/9). If the velo doesn’t bounce back, he may not be a top 20 starter this season.

Tyler Glasnow, TB (6 IP, 1 H, 0 ER, 0 BB, 6 K)

I’ve been out on Glasnow for, well, most of his career. Injury issues and merely two pitches don’t do it for me at the price you have to pay to acquire him (ADP 42 this year). However, as I mentioned in my Don’ts, he has been working to incorporate a new slider. That would finally give him a third offering. The Rays don’t typically let any starter see an order a third time through, but a third pitch still helps make Glasnow a legitimate starting option.

Glasnow game chart

As you can see, not only did Glasnow throw his slider plenty in his first start, but he threw 26 of them (33.8%) compared to just nine curveballs (11.7%). The slider allowed just two balls in play, earned two strikeouts, and no hits, with a 41.7% whiff rate. So…yeah. That’s pretty insane. He’s not going to pile up innings like the uber-aces, but with all the strikeouts he’s going to rack up, he has a very good chance at finishing inside the top 10 in my starting pitcher rankings.

Yusei Kikuchi, SEA (6 IP, 6 H, 3 ER, 1 BB, 10 K)

I’ll admit to being a Kikuchi Hoochie. I wasn’t exactly conducting the hype train in the spring, but I did passingly mention investing at his ADP in my Dudes. Well, if you nabbed him around his ADP of 282, you have to be encouraged with 10 K’s in his 2021 debut. While his fastball velo was the same as it was in 2020, his cutter and slider were both down 2-3 MPH.

Kikuchi starting pitcher rankings

This may actually be by design. It led to a sexy-time 40.4% CSW, although he still allowed some hard contact. He will be a fascinating player to follow this season. His ceiling is somewhat limited as long as the Mariners stick with a six-man rotation, however.

Taylor Widener, ARZ (6 IP, 3 H, 0 ER, 3 BB, 5 K)

Widener was true to his name, widening eyes as they gazed upon the glory of his first 2021 box score. Yes, I know that was a lame pun, but everything else I thought of would have been cut by the editors anyway. It’s an impressive line against a stout Padres lineup. Only starting for the Diamondbacks because of Gallen’s injury, Widener earned a sexy-time 38% CSW. The slider itself finished with a 43% CSW on 14 offerings (17% usage).

He has only ever pitched in relief at the highest level, posting a 4.50 ERA over 12 appearances (20 IP) last year. He can sure miss bats, but he also frequently misses the strike zone – he had 12 walks over those 20 innings in 2020. Home runs have also been a problem for him in the minors, as well as last year with Arizona.

Widener starting pitcher rankings

He was able to pound the zone with the fastball in this one, also locating his changeups down in and below the zone. If he can continue to do that, he may push Caleb Smith or Luke Weaver out of a starting gig. If not, he’ll be back at Triple-A or in the bullpen whenever Gallen returns.

Top 100 Starting Pitcher Rankings

RnkName
1Jacob deGrom
2Gerrit Cole
3Shane Bieber
4Aaron Nola
5Lucas Giolito
6Clayton Kershaw
7Trevor Bauer
8Yu Darvish
9Max Scherzer
10Walker Buehler
11Tyler Glasnow
12Lance Lynn
13Jack Flaherty
14Kenta Maeda
15Brandon Woodruff
16Luis Castillo
17Corbin Burnes
18Blake Snell
19Zack Wheeler
20Jose Berrios
21Sandy Alcantara
22Max Fried
23Kyle Hendricks
24Hyun Jin Ryu
25Zack Greinke
26Lance McCullers
27Pablo Lopez
28Aaron Civale
29Charlie Morton
30Dylan Bundy
31Patrick Corbin
32Joe Musgrove
33Chris Paddack
34Frankie Montas
35Jesus Luzardo
36Zach Plesac
37Marcus Stroman
38Ian Anderson
39Julio Urias
40Stephen Strasburg
41Tyler Mahle
42Shohei Ohtani
43James Paxton
44Yusei Kikuchi
45Freddy Peralta
46Michael Pineda
47German Marquez
48Triston McKenzie
49Mike Minor
50Ryan Yarbrough
51John Means
52Carlos Martinez
53Dustin May
54Trevor Rogers
55Dallas Keuchel
56Jameson Taillon
57Zach Davies
58Zach Eflin
59Nathan Eovaldi
60Matthew Boyd
61Carlos Rodon
62Kevin Gausman
63Robbie Ray
64Logan Webb
65Jordan Montgomery
66Tarik Skubal
67Brady Singer
68Corey Kluber
69Domingo German
70Dylan Cease
71Garrett Richards
72Andrew Heaney
73JT Brubaker
74Marco Gonzales
75Mitch Keller
76Jose Urquidy
77Sean Manaea
78Drew Smyly
79Adbert Alzolay
80Chris Bassitt
81Justus Sheffield
82Taijuan Walker
83Matt Shoemaker
84Tanner Houck
85Dane Dunning
86Casey Mize
87Griffin Canning
88Alex Cobb
89Luke Weaver
90Christian Javier
91Adrian Houser
92David Peterson
93JA Happ
94Brad Keller
95Chris Flexen
96Adrian Morejon
97Johnny Cueto
98Aaron Sanchez
99Taylor Widener
100Dani+A1:B101el Ponce de Leon

It’s never too early to tweak your roster! Head on over and check out Eric Cross’s first Fantasy Baseball Waiver Wire of the year and  David Mendelson’s Pitching Streamers!


Fantrax was one of the fastest-growing fantasy sites of 2020 and we’re not stopping now. With multi-team trades, designated commissioner/league managers, and drag/drop easy click methods, Fantrax is sure to excite the serious fantasy sports fan – sign up now for a free year at Fantrax.com.

6 Comments
  1. Rahil SULEMAN says

    No Gallen on the top 100?

    1. Nathan Dokken says

      I think I covered this one on Twitter but just in case that was someone else – I don’t rank IL’ed players unless their return is imminent.

  2. Chris says

    Sonny Gray?

    1. Nathan Dokken says

      As I mentioned in the intro, no IL’ed players will be ranked unless their return is imminent.

  3. BB says

    Not overly impressed by Hoffman vs. the Padres (5-3-1-1-0-6) and those 13 whiffs (though only a 31 CSW)?

  4. WUDI says

    I think Taylor is a great pitcher and I look forward to his performance

Leave A Reply

Your email address will not be published.