The Home of Fantasy Sports Analysis

Fantasy Baseball Black Book: Why Two-Catcher Formats Must Die

Editor’s Note: The following is taken from the 2018 Fantasy Baseball Black Book. It seemed appropriate to revisit this after Doug Anderson’s article lamenting the trend away from two-catcher formats.  The NEW Fantasy Baseball Black Book 2019 is available on Amazon right now!

If you’re like us you can’t wait until spring to get the 2019 fantasy baseball season started? Well, you don’t have to. Leagues are already forming at, so head on over and start or join a league today.


The industry standard (especially in “expert leagues”) continues to be the two-catcher format. This is an old standby that has lasted well past its golden age and I’m officially calling for its death! This is yet another example of baseball evolving and fantasy refusing to evolve with it in turn. Only Martin Maldonado and Yadier Molina caught 130+ games in 2017. In 2018, there were also just 2, Yasmani Grandal and Willson Contreras. In 2008, (just 10 short years ago), there were 10 guys who caught 130 games or more. Sure, there are some catcher eligible players that will DH, play 1B and help out elsewhere, but this idea of the “everyday” catcher is growing into extinction.

So, why are we still torturing ourselves with this ridiculous concept? Because we fear change. Because it’s “always been done this way”. Because we are lazy. All of the above are lame reasons and enough is enough! Still not sold? Ok, try this one on for size:

In 2007, 17 catchers had 400 at-bats or more.

In 2017 and 2018, there were nine. Nine!!!!!

You heard me, nine! What two-catcher formats really do is devalue the position as a whole. Draft a great catcher and a low level one, all you do is marginalize the good stats. Draft two mediocre ones, again marginal, mediocre results. Draft two crappy ones, all that draft capital goes to better players who impact your bottom line more effectively. However, if you make 12-15 teams fight over the top catchers, now there’s something to lose. If you miss out on an above average one, you may indeed fall behind in productivity.

Basically, my point is, if catchers aren’t even logging 400 at-bats, they’re not even getting the opportunity to be productive in fantasy. Therefore, why are are we trying to pump artificial value into a position that’s been devalued offensively in major league baseball? At it’s best, fantasy baseball is an accurate representation of the game we love that we control (to a certain extent). You don’t make something worth more by simply flooding the market with them. Ya know, like baseball cards!

It’s time to “#KillTwoCatcherFormats”!

Fantrax is one of the fastest growing fantasy sites of 2018. With multi-team trades, designated commissioner/league managers, and drag/drop easy click methods, Fantrax is sure to excite the serious fantasy sports fan – sign up now for a free year at

Leave A Reply

Your email address will not be published.