Dump Trades and the Keeper League Fix
As my wife will gladly tell you, I play a lot of Fantasy Baseball. I’ve cut down to seven leagues this year to focus more on my duties within the industry. I play mostly 5 X 5 Roto, but in various formats; two larger mixed leagues, one NL-only keeper league, two AL-Only keeper leagues, plus a couple category based head-to-head leagues that I need to do a better job in keeping up with. The keeper leagues I’m in have been through the wars, and it’s because of a problem that most every keeper league eventually faces; dump trades. They always happen and they almost always cause major controversy. Dump trades have even caused previous keeper leagues I’ve been in to disband.
If you’re like us you can’t wait until spring to get the 2019 fantasy baseball season started? Well, you don’t have to. Leagues are already forming at Fantrax.com, so head on over and start or join a league today.
Today I’m gonna talk about these dump trades and offer up a couple of suggestions for how your league can avoid the controversy that ruins many leagues. I’ve hit on this idea before, but usually during draft season when leagues might be forming. Maybe it’ll hit home more now when these very trades might be wreaking havoc in your league.
Part of the beauty of keeper leagues is that, by their very nature, the format ensures that owners remain active. Either you’re trading prospects or low-priced keepers for big stars, or you’re headed the other direction and trying to build for the future. That’s where dump trades come in and that’s where the trouble often starts.
In the event that you don’t know what dump trades are, the term refers to trades where one team gives up significantly more value during the current season, in exchange for more perceived future value. In most keeper leagues, salary and contract status also come into play in these trades. The obvious problem with dump trades is that a single trade can shift the balance of power in a league. When a team in the top few spots adds a couple of elite players in exchange for a few top prospects, it can seem unfair. In the here and now, it’s like they added huge production at no cost. This tends to get the other teams in contention a little fired up.
The Positive Aspects of Dump Trades
The first thing you need to come to grips with is that dump trades are going to happen. They’re necessary, but they’re not evil. In fact, they have several positive effects on your league.
- Dump trades give each owner the ability to shape their team as they see fit. If you’re a fantasy owner, no rule should keep you from building a competitive team, whether it’s the current season, or in the near future. It’s your team and you deserve the right to make the decisions.
- Dump trades ensure turnover in the standings. Everybody hates to see the same guy winning the league year after year (unless it’s you). With dump trades in play, any owner in contention very likely has to go all-in for the money; at least they do if they’re in a league with me. If they don’t add value I damn sure will and you’ll be looking at second place. This means that the teams at the top shifted a lot of future value to the bottom of the league. That’s a good thing.
- Dump trades combine the best aspects of Socialism and Capitalism. Think about it. Each team starts with the exact same resources when the league begins. No one has to break out of poverty to rise to the top. But each owner can then work the laws of supply and demand in order to build the best possible team. You get what your efforts deserve and no one is giving you a thing. Who can complain about that? If you end up ‘poor’, it really is your fault in a keeper league. Talk about personal accountability.
The Failed Remedies for Dump Trades
Throughout my fantasy baseball career, I’ve seen a variety of keeper league rules put in play to deal with the issue of dump trades.
First came the banning of trades between teams at extreme ends of the standings. The thinking is that if teams are closer in the standings, their needs will be more similar. This theoretically reduces the likelihood of extreme talent shifts in any one trade. The problem is it also completely eliminates a big portion of the league from being as active as they would like.
Less potential trade partners usually means a less than ideal return for everybody. The teams at the top stay at the top and the teams at the bottom have little opportunity for upward mobility.
The other big attempt to limit dump trades came in the form of salary cap minimums and maximums. The idea here is to penalize owners on both sides of the trade by making it extremely difficult to deal away or trade for too much talent (salary).
The real effect is that the teams dealing away all the salary usually ended up placing $60 FAAB bids on backup middle infielders. The teams on the receiving end of all that value usually just jettison their injured players or toss them back as part of the trade. And again this solution again limits trading and prevents an owner from running their team.
Way too many fantasy baseball leagues have way too many rules that can suck the fun out. I just want to pretend I know everything and run my damn team.
My Keeper League Fix for Dump Trades
There are certainly many ways to set up your keeper league rules, but here are two simple steps that can help mitigate the damage dump trades can do, while at the same time allowing owners to enjoy the process of building a winning fantasy baseball team.
- Get rid of bad owners: Nobody wants to be the asshole commissioner who throws his weight around. I’m telling you it’s OK. Fantasy Baseball is a game, but for those of you who’ve read this far, it’s an embarrassingly huge source of enjoyment — or at least it should be. There’s no reason to put up with the same bad owners who have no clue about evaluating talent or assigning value. It might take two or three seasons, but have the balls to get rid of bad owners. Everyone in the league will be happier in the end.
- Implement Use of The Dumping Proclamation: It’s a very simple idea. Any owner who wishes to play for the future must submit a dumping proclamation on the league message board or whatever system your league uses to communicate. That owner must then wait a minimum of one full week before completing any dump trades. And don’t act like we all don’t know what represents a dump trade. If you have to ask it isn’t… If you’ve weeded out the bad owners as I suggested, no self-respecting Fantasy Baseball genius is going to whine about a trade if they had the very same opportunity to acquire the players in question. This also ensures the dumping owner is likely to get the best deal possible and will hopefully result in the dumped talent being spread to multiple teams in the league. It’s good for the teams at the top, and it’s good for the teams at the bottom.
Let’s face it, Fantasy Baseball owners can be very competitive (and immature). There will be controversy at some point. We just don’t want it to be controversy that leads to the end of your league.
The suggestions I outlined above are very simple and best of all they don’t really limit what an owner can do. Do you and your league a favor. Cut the dead weight and implement “The Dumping Proclamation” in your keeper league rules.
If you’re starting a new keeper league or having trouble with the one you’re in, also check out my 8 Keys to Building an Awesome Fantasy Baseball Keeper League.
Doug Anderson is an 11-year veteran of the Fantasy Sports industry. His work has appeared on RotoExperts.com, Yahoo.com, SI.com, and NFL.com, as well as in the pages of USA Today’s Fantasy Baseball Weekly and various other magazines. Doug has participated in both LABR and Tout Wars, the two preeminent expert fantasy baseball leagues in existence. Doug was formerly the Executive Editor at RotoExperts and is now Managing Editor here at FantraxHQ. You can follow him on Twitter @RotoDaddy.
Fantrax is one of the fastest growing fantasy sites of 2018. With multi-team trades, designated commissioner/league managers, and drag/drop easy click methods, Fantrax is sure to excite the serious fantasy sports fan – sign up now for a free year at Fantrax.com.