Every year I tweak my annual take on Fantasy Baseball Auction Strategy. It details some of the basics of preparing for a fantasy baseball auction, allocating your budget, and bidding strategies. Basically, it covers some of the overarching tenets that apply to all auction drafts. I’m also in the final stages of my Mixed League Auction Strategy article. Believe it or not, the differences in the player pool necessitate vastly different approaches.
This article will supplement the previous ones with deep league auction strategy specifically for those of you in NL- and AL-Only leagues.
The season is not here yet, but why not get a head start and jump in a Fantrax Classic Draft contest? Get a jump on the season with a Best Ball league or maybe a Draft and Hold. Or put some green on the line with a new season-long league to try and conquer. There’s no better time than now to get your baseball on!
Deep League Auction Strategy
If you’re here reading this I don’t need to win you over on the auction format. You know the enjoyment and challenges they bring. So let’s get to it and try to figure out the formula for a successful auction.
Stars and Scrubs or Spread the Wealth?
Throughout the years since Rotisserie Baseball started in the early 1980’s there have been two basic approaches used in Fantasy Baseball auctions.
Stars and Scrubs espoused spending up big for a few big stars and then filling your roster out with low-value players hoping to hit on enough of them to support the big money players you rostered.
Spread the Wealth took a more balanced approach, meaning an owner likely passed on the most expensive players, but roster a bunch of solid players at fair prices and was left with very few holes.
I’ve always been more of a spread the wealth guy, especially in NL- or AL-Only leagues. In a mixed league, you can spend big on a few players and still get decent players in the end game. It’s also easier to find help on the waiver wire once the season begins. Blow your wad on a handful of players in a deep league and the bulk of your lineup is going to be filled by total bums with minimal or even negative value.
So with the changing landscape of baseball, which strategy works best in 2022 deep leagues? Do you spend big or spread it out? The answer is yes… Both… Okay, I realize I’m speaking out of both sides of my mouth. Here’s the lowdown.
Spread the Wealth on Hitting
I haven’t changed when it comes to offense in deep leagues. If you don’t spread your money around you end up with holes all over the place. Think the 2023 catcher pool, but filling up half your lineup. This likely means I won’t be rostering, Ronald Acuna, Aaron Judge, Shohei Ohtani, or any of baseball’s elite players in an auction league. What I will do is roster a bunch of ‘boring’ veterans with guaranteed starting jobs.
I want to fill my offense with reliable players I can count on to contribute to my counting stats. Among these veterans, I can also usually count on one or two to have career years and approach the production of some of the stars I bypassed. Think Matt Olson last year or Jose Abreu in 2019. This approach isn’t sexy and no one is calling you a genius at the draft, but in my experience, it leads to strong offenses that perform well across all five hitting categories.
Stars and Scrubs on Pitching
The changing usage when it comes to Major League starting pitchers means we have to change our approach in fantasy. Basically, all starting pitchers except the top few are not going as deep into games as they did even a few years ago. This means the elite arms are worth more than ever before, but the gap between the rest of the starting pitchers and middle relievers is being narrowed. This sets up the perfect scenario to use a stars and scrubs approach. In all honesty, I’ve leaned this way in deep leagues for a long time. The current environment means it will be all the more effective.
This approach means I’ll spend relatively big on two aces or near aces. I’ll also make sure I get two closers I feel like I can trust. I probably won’t go top shelf, but a couple of second-tier closers. That may be harder this year than in previous years because the state of MLB bullpens is a mess. Then I’ll fill my staff in with top middle relievers and hopefully starting pitching values I like. I’m looking for my staff at the start of the season to consist of five starting pitchers and four relievers.
The plan is to finish near the top in ERA, WHIP, and Saves, and hopefully stay with the pack in Wins and strikeouts, allowing me to make moves during the season if I need to make up ground. The danger is if one of the low-dollar pitching values I purchased falls flat, doing serious damage to my ERA and WHIP. For that reason, I make sure I have at least one more good reliever on my reserve roster as a safety valve.
Salary Allocation for Deep League Auctions
So with these two contrasting approaches for hitting and pitching, how do we allocate our $260? At the right is what I’ve been working on for my NL- and AL-Only auctions. Remember, it’s a guideline. I posted a similar chart in last year’s mixed league auction strategy piece and people were getting hung up on the specific dollar values. Tweak as you wish and if you go over on one number borrow it from another.
I’ve actually borrowed $2 from my usual hitting budget and put it toward pitching. Since I’m not chasing the big-money bats, it should still allow me to build a pretty deep and balanced offense. The challenge on the pitching side will be to get two starting pitchers to anchor my staff. I want one bonafide ace and another solid pitcher I trust. To get that ace I may need to borrow money from the $10 reliever slot or my $4 fifth starter. If starting pitchers get thrown out early I will probably have to adapt. I’ll personally be throwing out every elite hitter I can early in the auction.
The key thing to remember is that every auction is different. You have to go in with a plan, but you also need to adjust on the fly when things get sideways. Even more so than in a mixed auction you want to make sure you save money for the end game. It will make the difference between useful regular players and complete holes in your lineup.
Doug Anderson is a 14-year veteran of the Fantasy Sports industry. His work has appeared on RotoExperts.com, Yahoo.com, SI.com, and NFL.com, as well as in the pages of USA Today’s Fantasy Baseball Weekly and various other magazines. Doug has participated in both LABR and Tout Wars, the two preeminent expert fantasy baseball leagues in existence. Doug was formerly the Executive Editor at RotoExperts and is now Managing Editor here at FantraxHQ. You can follow him on Twitter @RotoDaddy.
Are you buying in on Tyler’s favorite bounce-back players? For more great analysis check out the 2023 FantraxHQ Fantasy Baseball Draft Kit!
I’d definitely keep Abreu. Yes, he costs more, but he’d be a major portion of your offense. I’m not a fan of Polanco at that price, so I would lean Canha over him. Early talk was that Polanco would not start at 2nd, but would be a type of super utility. Looks like he’ll be starting now, but I still see him fighting for ABs.
the Polanco situation was exactly why I didn’t like passing on Canha….AND I love Polanco, if he’s the full time 2nd baseman…. Now with the mysterious game pull yesterday due to a groin strain…. I suspect Polanco/Arraez essentially both have primary jobs 2nd/LF, but end up acting as joint utility guys, floating between: SS, 2nd, 3rd and LF. All told, I put their AB’s at 500/450.
I hope you’ll get this note, as I need some last minute “keeper” advice. Here’s the situation:
AL-ONLY 12 team 5×5 auction league, with 8 allowable keepers per team. I went for it last year, so have a relatively bad keeper list. I also picked up NL guys last year who are “must keeps” for me. Some keepers are obvious, but would love to hear which 8 players you would recommend I keep. Two comments: 1) 15 of top 20 SP being kept. I had 4 of those guys, but decided to trade Heaney for Buxton; 3) Three of the teams are expansion teams, so in essence have a separate “draft” of keepers from the discarded pool of possible keepers (after the first nine teams declare their keepers). “2” creates a strange dynamic, as now you have to worry about keepers in a different way.
Tanner Roark – $1
Franmil Reyes – $17
I must choose 6 of the following:
Luzardo – $8
McCullers – $3
Bassitt – $8
Canha – $10
Buxton – $17 (other teams will keep lots of speed; ceiling to high to ignore)
Polanco – $15 (will have dual eligibility; lots of SS to be kept)
Yandy Diaz – $2
Jose Abreu – $29 (lots of 1b kept at lower prices, but as you know, most a step down)
Lastly, i thought back to you and this article because both the article and your earlier advice were excellent.
PS: I asked this question over on Razzball and this was recommended:
Luzardo – $8
McCullers – $3
Bassitt – $8
Buxton – $17
Polanco – $15
Jose Abreu – $29
However, I’m disquieted by discarding Canha, who I may prefer to either Abreu or Polanco.
I’ve played AL-only auction for years and am for the first time debating my participation……
Any way, your article is excellent, but leaves me with one fundamental question: On a 9-11 team league, how do you possibly follow your recommendation? How many aces are there in the AL-Only format, or for that matter even really solid 2’s. Besides Cole, Bieber and Giolito, who do you think is worthy of $24? Put a different way, I suspect most teams will be forced to “spread-the-wealth” strategy.
If I play this year, I am “keeping” (8 limit) 4 SP’s from last year, despite basically being at value except in one or two cases:
McCuller $3 (One true keeper)
What do you think, despite going somewhat against your article’s advice?
Thanks for reading. The current state of pitching in the AL especially certainly presents some challenges. The salaries of keepers also come into play. Although I’m not a huge fan of Heaney, I like the pitchers you’re gonna keep. In fact, I consider Luzardo a borderline No. 2 despite his lackluster 2020. Bassitt is also very solid in AL-Only leagues. I guess my standards for No. 1-2 starter are different depending on league context.
As far as other ace/#2 types in the context of an AL-Only league, I’d include Greinke, Lance Lynn, Carlos Carrasco, Ryu, Maeda, Tyler Glasnow, Zach Plesac and maybe Bundy depending on how much you buy into him.
If I had your team, I’d probably do the same thing and swap some of the money I had allotted for SPs to offense. I’d still try to grab a couple low-WHIP middle relievers at the end of your draft as a safety valve for any of your starters that might be risky.
Maybe my big takeaway in mono-leagues is to stay away from pure innings-eater types. Heaney fits right on the edge of the type of starter I am leery of.
I like Heaney with the others, because together they are a really strong K base with good whip; each has an accretive k/9 compared to league. Heaney’s downfalls are health and HR/9, but the known downside is worth the gamble at $10. I should point out that anyone in my particular league with #2 capabilities has a $15+ value and true aces get stupid expensive. No doubt, Cole and Bieber would go $35+ in our league. In the end, I suspect our minimum innings forces carrying 6-7 SP’s, which makes true ace ballast Uber important.
Yeah, prices can get stupid real fast on the aces. Like I say, I think you’re sitting in a pretty good place with your pitching, especially because I think Luzardo will step it up. I’d add one more solid starter and maybe one or two gambles. Unless your IP requirement is crazy high, you should meet that easily. I typically reach the 900 IP threshold cycling through 6 starters, with good relievers who always stay in my lineup.