The Home of Fantasy Sports Analysis

2019 Catcher Review: Was It Really a Wasteland?

Sometimes you have to look back to move forward. You have to learn from history or it will repeat. I’m sure there are a few more cliches I’m missing, but I’m sure you’re getting the point. We’ve already turned our attention to 2020 here at FantraxHQ, but part of getting ready for next season involves taking inventory of the season we just finished. Thus over the next two months, you’re going to see a series of reviews, previews, and rankings for each of the positions we use in fantasy baseball. It all starts here with our 2019 Catcher Review… Don’t worry, it’s not gonna hurt as much as we thought it would.

We’ve already flipped the switch to 2020 mode here at FantraxHQ. Make sure you follow all of our Fantasy Baseball coverage to help gain an offseason edge over your competition!

2019 Catcher Review

The outlook was bleak heading into the 2019 season. All the talk was that the catcher position was a black hole devoid of value. If you look at the 2018 catcher stats it’s no wonder. Gary Sanchez hit just .186 with 18 homers. Willson Contreras dropped to 10 home runs and a .249 average. Things were not pretty, to say the least.

The picture at the end of the season looked a lot better. There was no one dominant catcher, but as a whole, the position provided a respectable depth of numbers. J.T. Realmuto provided the solid all-around season we expected. Sanchez hit just .232, but he rebounded with 34 HRs. Contreras faded a bit late in the season but still hit .272 with 24 long balls.

Mitch Garver was probably the biggest surprise at the position, finishing as the third-ranked catcher. Travis d’Arnaud also resurrected his career with a mini-breakout, hitting 16 homers to go with 69 RBI.

Most of us ignored Roberto Perez and James McCann as defense-only backstops. They laughed at us with a combined 42 home runs.

Speaking of combined, 2019 was a good year to double-up with catchers from the same team. If you paired the aforementioned Garver with teammate Jason Castro, you pocketed a nice 44 homers. Of course, we knew Seattle was a wealth of catcher value (we did?). Omar Narvaez and Tom Murphy tag-teamed their way to 40 bombs.

Danny Jansen was the rookie catcher we were watching heading into the 2019 season, but Will Smith of the Dodgers ended up being the only rookie who provided any real value.

In all, eight catchers hit 20 or more homers and a full 16 backstops hit 15 or more. The decent depth, but lack of many elite options means it will still be a position largely ignored heading into 2020 drafts, but at least we can expect to get a bit of power from the position.

Final 2019 Values and Stats

The rankings in our 2019 catcher review come from the Fangraphs Auction Calculator set up for a 15-team mixed league and using the final 2019 stats to work off of. You can sort this table by clicking on the headers of each column.

RnkPlayerAvg.RHRRBISB15-Team $
1J.T. Realmuto.2759225839$28
2Yasmani Grandal.2467928775$21
3Mitch Garver.2737031670$20
4Christian Vazquez.2766623724$20
5Gary Sanchez.2326234770$18
6Willson Contreras.2725724641$16
7James McCann.2736218604$16
8Wilson Ramos.2885214731$15
9Omar Narvaez.2786322550$15
10Jorge Alfaro.2624418574$11
10Travis d'Arnaud.2515216690$11
12Roberto Perez.2394624630$11
13Yadier Molina.2704510576$10
14Kurt Suzuki.2643717630$10
15Robinson Chirinos.2385717581$10
16Carson Kelly.2454618470$8
17Tom Murphy.2733218402$7
18Josh Phegley.2414512640$7
19Pedro Severino.2493713443$6
20Will Smith.2533015422$5
21Stephen Vogt.2633010403$4
22Victor Caratini.2663111341$3
23Brian McCann.2492812450$3
24Austin Romine.281298351$3
25Buster Posey.257437380$3
26Yan Gomes.2233612432$3
27Jason Castro.2323913300$2
28Tony Wolters.262421420$2
29Tucker Barnhart.2313211401$1
30Danny Jansen.2074113430$1
30Tyler Flowers.2293611340$1
32Francisco Mejia.265278221$0
33Curt Casali.251248320$0
34Martin Maldonado.2134612270$0
35Jonathan Lucroy.232308360-$1
36Welington Castillo.2091912410-$1
37John Hicks.2102913351-$1
38Willians Astudillo.268284210-$2
39Matt Wieters.2141511271-$2
40Kevan Smith.251215202-$3
41Alex Avila.207229241-$3
42Jacob Stallings.262266130-$3
42Chance Sisco.210298200-$3
44Elias Diaz.241312280-$3
45Austin Barnes.203285253-$3
46Russell Martin.220296201-$3
47Chris Iannetta.222206210-$4
47Isiah Kiner-Falefa.238231213-$4
49Reese McGuire.299145110-$4
50Austin Hedges.1762811361-$4

What’s your take on the catcher position for the 2020 season? Let us know in the comments below.

Fantrax is one of the fastest-growing fantasy sites of 2018/2019 and we’re not stopping anytime soon! With multi-team trades, designated commissioner/league managers, and drag/drop easy click methods, Fantrax is sure to excite the serious fantasy sports fan – sign up now for a free year at

Leave A Reply

Your email address will not be published.